Why Do Girls Choose Beta Guys Over High-Value Men

Today, I want to tackle a question that landed in my inbox recently. The email was titled “Why do girls not want me?” A guy wrote me, explaining that he sees himself as a “high-value man” with purpose and values, yet he can’t seem to attract women. He’s frustrated because girls are choosing so-called "beta" guys instead.

Let me break this down, step by step, so you can see where the disconnect happens and how to start shifting things in your favor.

Step 1: Stop Overthinking Labels

First off, if you’re calling yourself a “high-value man,” you’ve already lost. No real high-value man walks into a room announcing it. It’s like wearing a shirt that says, “I’m cool.” Cool people don’t do that, and confident men don’t either. Women sense this kind of self-labeling as insecure and overcompensating. The more you focus on proving your value, the more you telegraph to her that you don’t believe you have it.

Step 2: Values Don’t Equal Sex Appeal

Here’s the hard truth: having purpose and values makes you a great candidate for long-term commitment, but it doesn’t automatically make you attractive. Attraction is primal. It’s sparked by emotional highs, fun, unpredictability, and yes, sometimes by traits society labels as “bad.” If you’re leading with your career success or personal development, it’s like trying to sell a sports car by talking about its fuel efficiency—it’s missing the point.

Step 3: What Makes the “Beta” Guy Win?

You see these guys and think, “Why her? Why him?” But what you’re missing is how she feels around him. These so-called beta guys often have a laid-back attitude. They aren’t trying too hard to impress. They’re fun, present, and don’t bring heavy “husband material” energy into casual interactions. Women follow their emotions, and these guys make her feel good right now.

Step 4: It’s About the Vibe

A woman isn’t sitting there thinking, “Oh, I need a man with a five-year plan.” She’s thinking, “Does he make me laugh? Is he fun to be around? Does he seem confident without trying too hard?” That’s what wins in the short term.

If you’re focusing on heavy conversations like your career or goals, you’re skipping the attraction phase. Keep it light, playful, and engaging. Be the guy who’s genuinely having fun—she’ll naturally want to be part of your world.

Step 5: Stop Trying to Qualify Yourself

Here’s another mistake: working too hard on yourself just to attract women. If you’re hitting the gym or pursuing your goals just to “get the girl,” she’ll feel that energy, and it’s a turn-off. Real confidence comes from already feeling enough as you are. Improve yourself because it fulfills you, not because you’re expecting women to reward you for it.

Step 6: Embrace Her Reality, Not Yours

You call these guys “beta,” but she might see them as carefree, confident, or exciting. What matters isn’t your perspective but hers. If a woman is choosing someone, it’s because he fulfills an emotional need, whether or not he fits your label of “alpha” or “beta.” Attraction is subjective—adapt to what works instead of clinging to what “should” work.

The Takeaway

The next time you wonder why you’re not getting chosen, look at your approach. Are you too focused on proving your value? Are you leading with heavy, serious energy? Are you assuming women think like you do? Shift your mindset to this: Women want to feel something now. The more you focus on fun, confidence, and letting go of overthinking, the more magnetic you’ll become.

Remember, you attract what you are. Work on your internal value, and you’ll attract the right kind of woman into your life.

You are not a victim. You are a Headman.

Now it's time that we take the next step to develop you into the man that you were called to be.

Take the next step right here to join us inside this global movement.